Difference Between SIP and STP in Mutual Funds

What is SIP?

What is STP?

Key Differences Between STP vs SIP

Systematic Transfer Plans (STP) and Systematic Investment Plans (SIP) represent two alternative techniques for investing in mutual funds. Below is a comparison to differentiate these two types of investing:

Aspect SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) STP (Systematic Transfer Plan)
Definition A way to invest a fixed amount on a regular schedule into a mutual fund scheme. A method for transferring amounts systematically from one mutual fund scheme to another within the same fund house.
Source of Funds New contributions to an investment from income or funds on deposit. Uses a lump sum invested in a source fund, typically a liquid fund or debt fund.
Objective To build long-term wealth through disciplined investing. To diversify a portfolio, manage risk, and enhance returns through periodic funds transfers.
Investment Process Regularly, money is directly debited from the investor's bank account and invested in a mutual fund scheme. Money is transferred periodically from one mutual fund scheme (the source) to another mutual fund scheme (the target) within the same Asset Management Company (AMC).
Tax Implications Tax is only applied on the redemption of investments according to capital gains rules when dealing with equity or debt funds. All transfers are treated as redemptions, and capital gains tax is triggered at the time of transfer based on the holding period of the originating fund.
Rupee Cost Averaging It mitigates the impact of volatile markets by averaging purchase costs over time. It reduces market timing risk by timing transfers through time.
Flexibility Fixed amount on fixed intervals; can alter trade amounts or stop trades. Transfer amounts can be altered based on market conditions and transfer intervals.
Capital Appreciation No direct focus on capital appreciation in the investment phase. Provides for capital appreciation in the originating fund, allowing for the capital appreciation to be transferred as well.
Risk Mitigation Reduces risk through funding a consistent period and the impacts of rupee cost averaging. Reduces market timing risk by staggering transfers and balancing overall returns and risk between funds.
Liquidity Investments are generally liquid, but this varies by system and may be subject to exit loads or lock-in periods, depending on the type of scheme (e.g., ELSS). Provides liquidity by adjusting fund allocation while earning a return on idle funds in the originating scheme.
Suitable For People with jobs or regular income are looking for a consistent investment in equity funds. Investors who have a lump sum amount and want to maximise returns while switching from debt to equity funds, or vice versa, with time slowly leading into either strategy.
Convenience Automatic deductions enable effortless investment with minimal manual effort from the investor. Automatic transfers enable seamless investment without requiring users to process each transaction manually.

Types of SIP in Mutual Funds

Various types of SIPs are available, each for different financial objectives and preferences of investors. Key types include:

SIP Type Description
Regular SIP The most basic and common type of SIP is regular. In this type, you invest a fixed amount at a regular interval, often every month.
Top-Up SIP Top-Up SIP allows investors to increase their SIP monthly payment at intervals previously established.
Flexible SIP Flexible SIP allows you to adjust the scheduled amount of your investment at any time.
Perpetual SIP Perpetual SIP is programmed to continue indefinitely; there is no defined end date for the time it continues.
Trigger SIP Trigger SIPS are for more sophisticated investors who wish to invest based on their market models. Specifically, a user can set a trigger on the index level, NAV, or date.

Types of STP in Mutual Funds

There are several types of STP, each designed to serve specific investor objectives. Here are  several key types:

STP Type Description  
Fixed STP Transfers a fixed amount from one mutual fund to another at established timeframes. This simple approach helps reduce overall market risk. It works well for investors who prefer to be positively predictable.  
Capital Appreciation STP Transfers only the profit. As part of a capital appreciation STP, the original principal amount stays invested, and this type can work for investors looking to protect their base capital investment.  
Flexi STP Transfers a variable amount based on market conditions. The amount can change depending on fund performance. This gives experienced investors more control.  

SIP or STP - Which is Better?

FAQs about STP vs SIP

What makes SIP different from STP?

up-arrow
SIP allows a regular investment in a mutual fund, whereas STP allows for a transfer of funds from one mutual fund scheme to another.

When should I consider selecting SIP instead of STP?

up-arrow
When you are a salaried individual seeking a disciplined investment approach for small amounts of funds and a long-term financial goal, such as saving for retirement or a child's education.

Who gets the most benefit from STP?

up-arrow
STP is best suited for those with a lump sum amount they wish to invest, but on a systematic basis, to reduce market volatility over time and allow them to invest in mutual funds.

Can both an SIP and STP be used for investing?

up-arrow
Yes, you can set up an SIP to invest regularly and then establish an STP to gradually transfer a lump sum into an equity fund.

Does SIP assist in market timing?

up-arrow
Yes, SIP reduces market timing dangers by averaging the historical cost for investing over time using a present-value technique called rupee cost averaging.

Is STP an appropriate investment strategy in a volatile market?

up-arrow
Yes, STP helps diversify investment risk in a volatile market by spreading investments across a time horizon and may limit an investor's total exposure to a single mutual fund scheme.

Can I stop or change an SIP or an STP?

up-arrow
Yes, both SIP and STP allow investors to suspend, stop, or change their investment amount and frequency.

Which is more tax-efficient, SIP or STP?

up-arrow
SIPS are generally more tax-efficient because each investment is taxed only at redemption, while STPS treat every transfer from the source fund as a redemption and may attract capital gains tax at each step.

What is the minimum amount required for SIP or STP?

up-arrow
SIPs typically start at ₹500 per month, whereas STPs will depend on the total initial lump-sum investment made in a debt fund.

Can I set up an STP between different fund houses?

up-arrow
No, STP transfers can only occur between schemes of the same mutual fund company.

Is there any lock-in period for SIP or STP investments?

up-arrow
SIPs in ELSS funds would have a lock-in of 3 years, and the STP will depend on the exit load rules of the investment underlying fund.

What will happen if I miss a payment for my SIP?

up-arrow
If you miss a payment, the SIP will not be cancelled. It will recommence with the next scheduled payment.

Can I invest in more than one fund with a SIP or STP?

up-arrow
Yes, you can use SIPs and STPs to invest in multiple funds, and mutual funds allow you to set up multiple SIPs or STPs across different schemes to add diversification to your portfolio.

Can I automate both SIP and STP?

up-arrow
Yes, you can automate your SIP or STP investments with a mutual fund provider to make it convenient and consistent.

Which is better, SIP or STP?

up-arrow
SIP is better for investors who want to invest small amounts regularly without needing a lump sum, while STP is ideal for those with a lump sum who want to gradually move funds from a low-risk scheme to a higher-risk scheme.

What is the main difference between SIP and STP?

up-arrow
SIP involves regularly investing a fixed amount from your bank account into a mutual fund. In contrast, STP systematically transfers a fixed amount from one mutual fund scheme within the same fund house.

Disclaimer

up-arrow

  • This is an informative article provided on 'as is' basis for awareness purpose only and not intended as a professional advice. The content of the article is derived from various open sources across the Internet. Digit Life Insurance is not promoting or recommending any aspect in the article or its correctness. Please verify the information and your requirement before taking any decisions.
  • All the figures reflected in the article are for illustrative purposes. The premium for Coverage that one buys depends on various factors including customer requirements, eligibility, age, demography, insurance provider, product, coverage amount, term and other factors
  • Tax Benefits, if applicable depend on the Tax Regime opted by the individual and the applicable tax provision. Please consult your Tax consultant before making any decision.

Latest News

Currently there are no news to show.

Read More

Renew & Download Policy Document, Check Challan, Credit Score, PUC & more

Anytime, Anywhere. Only on Digit App!

google-play-icon

Rated App

app-store-icon

Rated App