Car Insurance
digit car insurance
usp icon

9000+ Cashless

Network Garages

usp icon

96% Claim

Settlement (FY23-24)

usp icon

24*7 Claims

Support

Up to 90% Off with PAYD Add-On
This is a {{carWheelerCtrl.localStorageValues.product}} reg no, please enter a private car reg no.

Click here for new car

I agree to the  Terms & Conditions

It's a brand new Car
usp icon

9000+ Cashless

Network Garages

usp icon

96% Claim

Settlement (FY23-24)

usp icon

24*7 Claims

Support

Difference Between Comprehensive vs Collision Car Insurance

What is Collision Car Insurance?

What is Comprehensive Car Insurance?

Key Differences Between Comprehensive vs Collision Car Insurance

Understanding the difference between comprehensive and collision insurance helps you select the appropriate coverage for your vehicle. The table below breaks down the differences between the two:

Aspect Comprehensive Insurance Collision Insurance
Type of Protection Covers non-collision damages like theft, fire, vandalism, floods, and animal strikes. Covers damage from crashes, including collisions with other cars or objects.
Cause of Damage Applies to incidents outside your control, such as weather events or theft. This applies when your car is damaged in an accident, regardless of who is at fault.
Best For Ideal for drivers in areas with high theft rates, extreme weather conditions, or wildlife hazards. Useful for drivers who want coverage for accident-related repairs.
Cost Generally affordable because it covers non-collision events. More expensive, as it covers a wider range of common accidents.
Real-Life Example A storm knocks down a tree, which falls into your car, damaging it. You accidentally hit a pole while parking, causing damage to your car.

Do You Need Both Collision and Comprehensive Insurance for Your Car?

Pros of Collision and Comprehensive Car Insurance

Collision and comprehensive insurance provide valuable protection against various types of risks. The table below highlights their key advantages:

Aspect Collision Insurance Comprehensive Insurance
Accident Coverage Insures your car against road accidents, particularly those involving collisions. Protects against non-collision damages like theft, fire, vandalism, and natural disasters.
Financial Protection It protects from heavy bills and repair costs after a road accident. It helps cover the cost of car repairs or replacement in the event of a total loss.
Peace of Mind Reduces stress by covering accident-related repair costs. Ensures financial security in the event of any unexpected occurrence.
Claim Processing Provides quick settlement approval, helping repairs start sooner. It provides insurance claims based on the car's current value, rather than its original value.

Cons of Collision and Comprehensive Car Insurance

While both types of insurance offer essential protective coverage against some risks, they also have disadvantages. The table below summarises their key disadvantages:

Drawback Comprehensive Insurance Collision Insurance
High Cost Comprehensive insurance generally has the highest premiums, especially for new or luxury cars. Typically, higher premiums for insurance are required, especially for high-risk drivers.
Deductibles Requires the insured to pay a deductible before the insurance coverage takes effect. Requires payment of a deductible before the insurance pays for repairs.
Depreciation Factor Payments are based on the car's "actual cash value." Covers only repair or replacement costs up to a car's current market value.
Limited Coverage Doesn't cover mechanical failures and wear and tear. Doesn't cover damages from natural disasters or theft.
May Be Unnecessary It might not be cost-effective for older cars. Older vehicles may not be worth insuring with collision coverage.

How to Choose the Right Car Insurance Coverage for Your Needs?

Deductibles in Comprehensive and Collision Car Insurance

Which is Better - Comprehensive or Collision Car Insurance?

FAQs about Comprehensive vs Collision Insurance