hamburger
×
Digit General Insurance Logo
phone icon
Powered By Digit
  1. Digit Insurance
  2. Motor Insurance
  3. Car Insurance
  4. Tips
  5. CNG vs Petrol Car
close
Renew Car Insurance

9000+ Cashless Garages

96% Claims Settled (FY 23-24)

Check Premium Check Premium

CNG vs Petrol Car: Which One Should You Choose?

cng vs petrol

Choosing between a CNG and a petrol car can be overwhelming. Both have advantages of their own, but what would suit you best? CNG cars are more environmentally friendly and economical. If fuel economy and environmental concerns matter, go for CNG. 

On the contrary, petrol-powered cars can give you more power and convenience. Thus, they appeal to performance and long-distance driving people. Continue reading to gain insights on the significant differences that might help you choose a suitable car.

Table of Contents

arrow-icon

What is a Petrol Car?

A petrol car runs on the widely available liquid fuel known as gasoline. These cars provide a smooth ride, fast acceleration, and full force. The common use of these cars extends from cities to highways because they are convenient. Petrol cars require less maintenance and provide constant power. 

These cars can travel long distances and offer a good, comfortable ride. However, they have a hefty fuel cost and higher pollution rates. These cars have better boot space since they do not need spare fuel tanks. They refuel very fast, making them suitable for long road trips. However, running them might become expensive due to increasing petrol prices.

What is a CNG Car?

A CNG car runs on Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) instead of petrol or diesel. It is fuel-efficient and cost-effective, hence cheap to run. Most people use CNG cars for their daily trips to save money. CNG cars emit a few harmful gases. However, the huge CNG tank consumes a lot of space in the boot. This lack of boot space results in limited luggage capacity.

CNG cars require constant tuning and cylinder checks for safety. Finding refuelling stations for CNG cars is difficult, especially outside the major cities. However, these cars are popular because they are cost-effective.

Key Differences Between CNG vs Petrol Cars

The selection between CNG and petrol cars involves understanding their different characteristics. While both serve the same purpose, they differ in performance, cost, environmental impact, and maintenance. The table below outlines the key differences among the two:

Parameter CNG Cars Petrol Cars
Fuel Cost CNG gives lower fuel costs and better mileage. It is cheaper than petrol, making it more economical for daily usage. It is more costlier than CNG cars, making the running costs higher.
Performance CNG cars offer very low power and acceleration. Engine performance is lower than petrol cars, causing a speed reduction. Petrol cars have smooth power delivery and swift acceleration. They have better performance in general for long drives.
Environmental Impact CNG has less emission, and hence, it is eco-friendly. It reduces air pollution and carbon footprint. Petrol cars leave more CO2 and result in air pollution. It is less eco-friendly because of its high emissions.
Maintenance CNG vehicles require periodic servicing and cylinder examination. These help in proper maintenance. Petrol cars have low maintenance costs. Regular service and oil changes keep them moving.
Refuelling Infrastructure The number of CNG stations is limited, so refuelling becomes difficult. Stations are hard to find in remote areas. Petrol stations are abundant and relatively easy to access. A petrol car can be refuelled quickly anywhere.
Boot Space The CNG tank occupies a significant amount of boot space. This leaves less space in the vehicle for luggage.  Petrol cars have an entire boot space without any limitations. You can carry more luggage or keep extra items.
Resale Value Their resale values are relatively low because not many buyers favour them. They also depreciate quickly because of the limited resources that refuel them. Their resale values are relatively high because petrol cars are primarily accepted and preferred in the second-hand market.

Performance Comparison of CNG and Petrol Cars

In terms of performance, CNG and petrol cars have distinct experiences. The table below highlights these key differences:

Parameter CNG Cars Petrol Cars
Engine Performance CNG engines provide adequate performance but can be sluggish. The power is less than that of the petrol engines, especially on highways. Petrol engines give better throttle response. They provide a smoother, more dynamic performance in all road conditions.
Noise and Vibration CNG engines are silent with minimal vibration. They give a smoother ride at low speeds. Petrol engines produce more noise and vibration, particularly during acceleration. This is noticeable at high speeds.
Driving Experience CNG cars are not as responsive as petrol cars. These are best for city driving with a lesser emphasis on speed. Overall, the driving experience is better with a petrol car. They work wonderfully in performance, handling and long-distance driving.

Cost Comparison of CNG and Petrol Cars

Pricing is usually a key factor for choosing one type of vehicle over another. While CNG has a lower fuel cost, petrol cars may offer better mileage at a higher cost. The key differences based on cost are given below:

Factor CNG Car Petrol Car
Initial Cost Higher due to CNG kit installation. Lower upfront cost.
Fuel Cost Lower than petrol, leading to savings. Higher, making running costs expensive.
Mileage Better mileage, reducing fuel expenses. Lower mileage compared to CNG.
Maintenance Requires frequent servicing and cylinder checks. Lower maintenance needs.
Long-Term Savings Significant fuel cost savings over time. Higher overall fuel expenditure.

Environmental Impact of CNG vs Petrol

Environmental considerations impact the decision between CNG and petrol cars.  The key differences based on environmental impact are as follows:

Parameter CNG Cars Petrol Cars
Carbon Emissions Emit lower CO2 and harmful gases. Reduce the greenhouse gas effect. Help maintain clean air. Release more CO2 per kilometre. Increase the effects of global warming. Cause more environmental harm over time.
Air Quality Impact Lower levels of emission of nitrogen oxides and particulate matter. Improve urban air quality significantly. Emits higher levels of NOx, CO, and fine particles. Contributes to the formation of smog.
Fuel Combustion Burns cleaner, with fewer toxic residues. The engine lasts longer because of efficient combustion. Oil contamination is less. Carbon deposits and unburnt hydrocarbons increase in quantity. More maintenance is required for the engine.
Resource Consumption Use natural gas, which is more abundant than crude oil. Rely less on imports, hence reducing the fuel costs.  It relies on fossil fuel, which is a depleting resource. Thus increasing the dependence on fuel imports.

Advantages of Petrol and CNG Cars

While petrol is better for on-road performance, CNG is cheaper and less polluting to the environment. Choosing one over the other is more in the hands of the individual users. The table below provides the pros of both to help you make a decision:  

Advantages of Petrol Cars Advantages of CNG Cars
Refuelling is easily accessible as petrol stations are located abundantly. CNG emits fewer harmful pollutants, making it certainly cleaner for the environment.
There is a good chance petrol engines have more reason for power and power delivery. CNG emits fewer emissions, such as carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides.
Petrol vehicles are generally more affordable than CNG-powered vehicles. CNG costs much less than petrol, so you save on costs.
Topping up a petrol vehicle can also be done quickly, and it only takes a matter of minutes. Maintenance costs can be lower with inboards, as CNG engines have low wear and tear.
There are more petrol vehicle options, and all petrol vehicles offer a wider range of options overall. CNG engines, in general, are much quieter than petrol engines.
Petrol cars are ideal for long journeys, as they offer a longer range. Going CNG does help reduce your overall carbon footprint.

Disadvantages of Petrol and CNG Cars

Despite the many benefits, both petrol-fuelled cars and CNG-powered cars have their downsides. Petrol cars are costly to operate and environmentally hostile, while CNG cars have fewer filling stations and lower boot space. The table below lays out the cons of each one:

Disadvantages of Petrol Cars Disadvantages of CNG Cars
Petrol is on the higher end of the cost spectrum compared to CNG, adding to running costs. CNG refuelling stations are not readily available, making it difficult to refuel.
Petrol vehicles emit more harmful gases like CO2 and particulate matter. CNG tanks will take up space in the boot, leaving less room for other uses.
Petrol engines require a higher rate of service and maintenance. CNG vehicles generally lack the same power and acceleration as petrol engines.
Petrol vehicles rely heavily on oil prices, which fluctuate often. Due to the cost of the conversion kit and CNG tank, purchasing a CNG vehicle may be more expensive upfront.
Petrol prices can change, affecting your monthly fuel payments. There are fewer models of CNG vehicles, limiting consumer choice.
Petrol engines will not be as fuel-efficient as CNG vehicles. CNG cars have a shorter driving range due to their lower energy density.

Which is Better - CNG or Petrol Cars?

A decision between a CNG and a petrol vehicle is based on preferences. CNG vehicles are cost-effective and environmentally friendly, while petrol vehicles offer more power and convenience.

When is a CNG Car Superior?

CNG vehicles are ideal for individuals seeking fuel efficiency and reduced emissions. Here's why a CNG car is better:

  • Reduced Fuel Price Volatility: CNG is as stable in price as petrol. This makes long-term budgeting easier. Petrol users are hit harder by fuel cost spikes.
  • Government Incentives: Most governments provide subsidies for CNG vehicles. Tax credits and rebates make them even cheaper.
  • Smooth Engine Performance: CNG engines generate fewer vibrations and noises. This means the drive is smoother. The engine also remains cleaner.

When is a Petrol Car Superior?

Petrol vehicles are a preferable choice for individuals who require power and convenience. Here's why it is better than a CNG car:

  • Improved Pickup and Acceleration: Petrol engines react more quickly to throttle input. They provide faster acceleration and are enjoyable to drive. 
  • Better for Remote Regions: Petrol pumps are also found in secluded areas. This provides smooth travel. Compressed natural gas (CNG) pumps are primarily located in cities.
  • No Power Loss Over Time: CNG engines lose performance over time. Petrol engines retain their efficiency for longer periods.

How to Convert a Petrol Car into a CNG Car?

Petrol car owners should consider CNG conversion because it lowers their expenses while decreasing environmental pollutants. The growing cost of petrol and governmental backing for environmentally friendly fuels have triggered a surge in CNG conversion popularity as an economically sustainable solution. 

Below are several key pointers that will help you to understand how to convert a petrol car into a CNG car:

  • A petrol car can be easily converted to a CNG car by installing a CNG kit, which comprises mounting a CNG tank, fuel lines, and an injection system. 
  • Qualified professionals should be used for this conversion process only. The installation of the kit involves modifying the fuel intake system. 
  • The mechanic connects the CNG kit to the engine and calibrates it to ensure proper operation. Proper tuning ensures efficient fuel flow and avoids performance problems.
  • After conversion, maintenance is required. CNG cars require periodic cylinder checks and leak tests. 
  • Owners must also update the vehicle's registration and insurance to reflect the change in fuel type.

In conclusion, choosing a CNG vehicle provides cost-effectiveness, lower running expenses, and environmental benefits. In contrast, petrol cars deliver better performance, faster-fueling capability, and wide-ranging fuel availability, but demand increases running expenses. 

Your choice between petrol and CNG vehicles should be determined by saving money, being environmentally friendly, or relying on power and convenience.

FAQs about CNG vs Petrol Cars