hamburger
×
Digit General Insurance Logo
Powered By Digit
Renew Car Insurance

9000+ Cashless Garages

96% Claims Settled (FY 23-24)

Comparing Sedans vs SUVs & Which One is Better for You?

What is a Sedan Car?

Sedan

What is a Sedan Car?

Sedans are passenger-car models characterised by low ground clearance and a sleek, three-box design with separate bays for the engine and cabin, along with a trunk. They are designed for comfort and aerodynamics, which is why they are popular in the city, where professionals often drive them.

Key characteristics of sedans include the amount of fuel consumed and the high-quality handling. This results in a lower centre of gravity, enhancing stability.

What is an SUV?

suv

What is an SUV?

SUVs, an abbreviation for Sport Utility Vehicles, offer consumers both the punch of off-roading and the ease of transportation for their families. Boasting higher clearances, they provide a durable structure and larger internal space while serving as utility vehicles for various purposes on different surfaces and activities.

It appeals due to its rugged road handling conditions and ample passenger and cargo space. Whether going up or down hills or loading the car for a long road trip, one can enjoy a safe and comfortable journey in an SUV.

Key Differences Between Sedans and SUVs

When choosing between a sedan and an SUV, there are certain factors to consider. The two differ in design, functionality, performance, and price. 

Aspect Sedan SUV
Size & Design Compact, sporty, low profile Tall, commanding, rugged
Driving Environment Best for cities, narrow streets Ideal for rural, highways, and uneven roads
Seating Position Low, ground-hugging Elevated, better road visibility
Fuel Efficiency High mileage, low emissions Lower mileage, higher emissions
Comfort Cosy, suitable for small families Spacious, ideal for large families and long drives
Safety Excellent crash performance, lower rollover risk Advanced safety, higher rollover risk in some models
Cost Budget-friendly Premium pricing and maintenance
Height Low profile Tall profile
Length Compact Longer, more interior and boot space
Legroom Moderate Generous for all passengers
Boot Space Smaller trunk, limited for heavy luggage Large boot, foldable seats for more space
Use Case City errands, office runs Road trips, family outings, adventure gear

Comparing Performance & Efficiency of Sedans vs SUVs

Performance and efficiency are the most crucial factors in selecting a car. Both sedans and SUVs have different strengths in this direction for other customers.

Feature Sedan SUV
Engine Power Moderate, ideal for daily commuting High torque and power, suitable for off-road and towing
Off-Road Capability Limited Excellent with AWD/4WD models
Highway Performance Smooth, steady Powerful and stable
Snow & Rain Performance Good grip on dry and wet roads Superior control with better traction systems
Fuel Economy Excellent Average, depends on engine size and weight

Safety Features Comparison of Sedans vs SUVs

The most crucial concern when choosing a car is safety. Both sedans and SUVs are equipped with the latest safety features, but their performance may vary in given situations.

Safety Aspect Sedan SUV
Frontal Crash Test High ratings, especially in newer models Varies by model, generally high
Side Impact Test Effective protection Excellent due to larger frame
Rollover Risk Low, stable due to low centre of gravity Higher, but many have stability control
Advanced Safety Features ABS, lane assist, airbags Includes advanced systems like auto braking, 360° cameras
Weather Safety Good in rain, average in snow Excellent in snow and off-road terrains

Comparing Cost & Ownership of Sedan & SUVs

Cost is one of the most critical factors that any car buyer considers. Comparing upfront and long-term ownership costs will help determine the best option. 

Cost Aspect Sedan SUV
Purchase Price Lower, affordable options Higher, especially for premium variants
Insurance Costs Low, due to compact size High, reflects bigger body and repair costs
Maintenance & Repairs Economical, widely available parts Expensive, specialised servicing required
Fuel Costs Low, due to better mileage High, due to large engines
Resale Value Depreciates faster Retains value longer
Longevity Great for regular use High lifespan, robust build

Pros and Cons of Sedans

When choosing a sedan, weigh the pros and cons. Here are the main benefits and drawbacks of owning a sedan:

Pros Cons
Fuel Efficiency: Sedans are generally more fuel-efficient than SUVs due to their lighter weight and smaller size, helping you save on fuel costs. Limited Space: Sedans offer limited interior and boot space, which may not suit larger families or those needing more room.
Their compact size and low height make sedans easier to handle and park, especially in congested city areas. Sedans struggle on rough or uneven roads and are not ideal for areas prone to flooding or poor terrain.
Sedans are usually more affordable to buy and maintain. Insurance costs are also typically lower than those for SUVs. Sedans are not designed for outdoor adventures like camping or off-roading, and their boots may not fit oddly shaped items.
Built lighter and lower to the ground, sedans offer reduced body roll and a smoother driving experience. The low-seating position in sedans may result in limited road visibility, especially in traffic or around larger vehicles.

Pros and Cons of SUVs

SUVs have grown popular due to their rugged offers, cross-functionality, and many features. It entails spacious areas, high ground clearance, and the capability to drive off-road, making them suitable for various driving conditions and lifestyles. Key benefits and drawbacks of the SUV include:

Pros Cons
SUVs provide generous boot and cabin space, perfect for carrying passengers, luggage, or large loads during long trips. Due to their larger size and weight, SUVs consume more fuel, making them costlier to run over time.
Many SUVs come with AWD or 4WD and are designed to handle tough roads, making them great for bad weather or off-road drives. Their larger build makes SUVs harder to park in tight city spaces or standard-sized parking spots.
The elevated seating provides a better view of the road, improving visibility and making it easier to navigate obstacles. SUVs cost more to maintain and repair, including more expensive parts like larger tyres and complex systems.
The size and weight of SUVs often result in better safety ratings, offering added protection during collisions. SUVs have a higher centre of gravity, making them more prone to rollover accidents compared to sedans.

Who Should Buy a Sedan or an SUV?

Environmental Impact of Sedans and SUVs

Sedans are more environmentally friendly than SUVs because they weigh less and consume fewer gallons of fuel. Here is a table outlining the environmental impact of each:

Aspect Sedans SUVs
CO2 Emissions Lower emissions result from a lighter design and smaller engines.  Higher emissions due to larger size and engine capacity.
Fuel Efficiency Higher mileage, ideal for urban and highway use.  Lower mileage; fuel consumption increases with size and weight.
Fuel Types Widely available in petrol, diesel, hybrid, and electric variants. Hybrids and EVs are more available but heavily rely on diesel/petrol.
Environmental Impact Smaller footprint, less fuel consumption. A larger footprint, but one that is improving as EV and hybrid technologies advance.

Factors to Consider Before Buying a Sedan or SUV

Every buyer's needs differ due to regional tastes, emerging trends and lifestyle demands. Only when one knows these points can one determine whether or not the car fulfils personal demands. Here are key factors to consider:

Factor Sedan SUV
Urban Regions Although the car is high, it is compact and fuel-efficient. Additionally, the car is well-suited for compact roads. Moderate, depending upon space.
Rural/Off-Road Low because of the limitations they have. High because of off-road ruggedness and versatility.
Emerging Economies Affordable sedans dominate the market. SUVs are on the rise with an increase in the income level.
Electric Vehicle Trends Electric sedans offer the advantages of higher energy efficiency and longer driving ranges, which are valuable features in an urban package. Electric SUVs, with spacious interiors and an elevated driving position, can consume more energy because of their size and weight.
Family Size For small families or individuals. For large families or frequent travellers.
Driving Conditions Best for city and highway driving. Excellent for mixed terrains and off-road.
Cargo Needs Limited, ideal for light usage. Ample, perfect for heavy-duty needs.
Fuel Efficiency and Performance Sedans will be more fuel-efficient and economical for a daily run. While less fuel-efficient, SUVs give you an overpowering performance and lure those whose top priorities are strength and versatility.

In conclusion, choosing between a sedan and an SUV depends on lifestyle, driving needs, and budget. Sedans are the perfect vehicle for city driving; they are stylish and easy to manoeuvre in congested areas. SUVs, in contrast, are rugged and spacious and have an excellent road presence.

Both have their pros and cons, ranging from safety and comfort to economic and environmental impact. Determining your priorities, driving habits, and long-term objectives can help you choose the right vehicle for your needs. 

FAQs about Sedans and SUVs