Buy Car Insurance Online

6000+ Cashless

Network Garages

Zero Paperwork

Required

24*7 Claims

Support

Get Instant Policy in Minutes*

Registration Number

+91 Mobile Number

I agree to the Terms & Conditions

Don’t have Reg num?

It's a brand new Car

6000+ Cashless

Network Garages

Zero Paperwork

Required

24*7 Claims

Support

Difference Between Automatic and Manual Transmission in Cars Explained

Manual vs Automatic Transmission in Cars

If you are on the verge of buying a car, many unanswered questions can be on your mind. A common confusion can be between choosing a manual or automatic transmission.

In general, if you are driving a manual car, you are responsible for shifting the gears. However, if you choose an automatic transmission car, it automatically senses and shifts gears whenever necessary.

Keep reading further to better understand the difference between automatic and manual cars.

Team Digit

What is a Manual Transmission?
Pros and Cons of Manual Cars
What is an Automatic Transmission?
Pros and Cons of Automatic Cars
Manual vs Automatic Transmission
Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Manual Transmission Car?

Simply put, manual gear enables drivers to select a gear ratio to drive their car. The type of gear ratio they opt for determines the vehicle's torque and speed. For instance, choosing a lower gear ratio will result in more torque but less speed. Likewise, higher gear ratios offer less torque but more speed.

Furthermore, the countershaft constantly gets meshed into the input shaft, which is comprised of multiple gears in a manual transmission car. The output shaft, countershaft, driveshaft, and wheels are interconnected. When you drive your car, the output shaft first sends its connection to the transfer case. In the case of the reverse gear, it generally connects the fourth shaft for changing direction.

It is also essential to have a brief idea about an automatic transmission car before discussing automatic vs. manual cars.

What are the Pros and Cons of Manual Transmission Cars?

Manual transmission cars have their share of pros and cons, and it all boils down to customer preferences. Some of the pros and cons are highlighted in the table below:

Pros	Cons
More entertaining and enjoyable to operate.	They can be tiring, especially when your car is caught up in traffic.
Gears and shifting are entirely under the control of the car's driver.	Slope learning curve where new drivers need to exert a lot of effort.
They are most often less expensive than their automatic counterparts.	Usually, it is not included in the premium or higher trims of the car.
It is cheaper and less complicated to address its breakdown and effectiveness.	Lacks adequate power when going uphill and requires compassionate handling to prevent the vehicle from stalling.
Increased efficiency of fuel in the older models	Newer models, compared to modern automatics, have lower fuel efficiency.
Improved handling in sporty automobiles	Maybe less comfortable for stop-and-go city driving
Better resale value for sporty models	Restricted availability as fewer new car models have manual transmission options
Enables engine braking during sharp descends	Less easy for other people to get access to your car

What is an Automatic Transmission Car?

As the name indicates, with an automatic car, you do not need to manually shift gears. They help in directing the rational force and controlling the car's speed. In short, the automatic transmission automatically shifts gear ratios as the vehicle moves. It detects the speed through its sensors and sends signals to automatically shift gears appropriately.

You can easily identify whether a car is automatic or manual. If your car features two pedals, then it's an automatic car. Manual cars feature a third pedal commonly known as the clutch pedal. A clutch pedal is smaller in size in comparison to the brake pedals.

Apart from this, you also know that there is not just one but different types of automatic transmissions. Torque converter automatic is the most common among all, followed by the continuously variable transmission or CVT, which enables an infinite number of gear ratios without interruption. A semi-automatic transmission (SAT) is more or less similar to a manual transmission. The other types include dual-clutch transmission and Tiptronic transmission.

What are the Pros and Cons of Automatic Transmission Cars?

Learning about the pros and cons of automatic cars is essential to help you make an informed decision based on one's driving preferences. The pros and cons of automatic cars are highlighted in the table below:

Pros	Cons
Less challenging to navigate, especially in regions with a lot of traffic	The purchase cost is significantly higher than that of manual cars.
More convenient, especially for inexperienced drivers.	Typically, it is more complicated and costly to repair.
DCT or dual-clutch transmission provides a fast shift for enhanced performance.	Less exciting to drive, which may be subjective
Usually, it offers a more comfortable driving experience.	Slightly reduced economy in some models
Nowadays, it can be installed in most vehicle models	There may be too many gear changes in transmission.
Changes faster and more smoothly	The driver has less control over the gear.
Some models are more economical, particularly new models, in terms of fuel consumption.	Higher long-term operating costs
Automatic with manual control is a valuable feature for many users	May not be as sporty for a focused enthusiast

What is the Difference Between Manual and Automatic Transmission in Cars?

Refer to the table below to understand what is the difference between manual and automatic cars:

Parameter	Manual Transmission	Automatic Transmission
Price	Cars that come with manual transmission cost less.	The price of an automatic transmission is relatively high.
Cooling	Manual transmission cars do not require active cooling	Automatic cars often face overheating problems and thus require active cooling
Fuel efficiency	Manual transmission cars are more fuel efficient and depend on drivers' driving skills.	It could be more fuel-efficient than a manual transmission and can be driven by less skilled drivers.
Driving	It would be best to have much more focus and attention when driving a manual transmission car.	Thanks to its sensors, driving an automatic transmission car requires little focus and attention.
Number of pedals	There are three pedals in a manual transmission car: acceleration, brakes, and clutch	There’s no clutch pedal in an automatic transmission car. The shift in gears takes place automatically depending on the car's speed
Control	You exercise more control over your vehicle when you drive a manual transmission car.	An automatic transmission does not allow you to exercise 100% control of your car.
Ease of driving	Manual transmission cars are challenging to drive on high-density roads.	Due to the automatic gear change capability, an AT car is much easier to drive in high traffic.
Design complexity	Manual transmission cars exhibit a simple design, as they feature minimal components.	An automatic transmission car exhibits a complex design due to its multiple components.
Number of gears	An MT car features different gear sets to perform different gear ratios	The same gears perform different gear ratios in an AT car
Mileage	The difference between a manual and an automatic car is the mileage offered; it's pretty high for MT.	The mileage offered by an automatic car is slightly lower.
Required skill level	A manual transmission car might not be an excellent choice for new drivers.	Automatic transmission cars make it easy for new drivers to drive.

In conclusion, the differences between a manual and an automatic car are but a few. Therefore, choose an automatic or manual transmission car depending on your budget and what you are looking for in your car.

Know more about:

FAQ's about Difference Between Manual and Automatic Cars

All

Which car is better manual gear or automatic?

From the driver's perspective, an automatic car is more comfortable and easier to drive regularly. Contrarily, a manual transmission car provides more control to the driver and is more pocket friendly.

Is manual faster than automatic?

Unlike an automatic transmission car, as a driver, you get to exercise more control on a manual transmission car. Thus, you can drive it at any speed without any technology alerting you not to. However, this practice is pretty risky, so being cautious is recommended.

Why are manual cars cheaper?

A manual transmission car is not technologically advanced and doesn't include multiple complicated components. Hence, it is much cheaper than an automatic transmission car.

Do manual cars give better mileage than automatic?

Multiple drivers remark that manual transmission cars have better fuel efficiency, as the car's motor does not perform multiple activities, unlike an automatic transmission car, thus resulting in lesser fuel consumption.

What is the difference between automatic and manual cars?

The main difference between automatic and manual cars is how the transmission works. The driver manipulates the gear in a manual car through the clutch and gear lever. Automatic cars have gear shifts that are also done automatically according to the driving condition.

Are automatic cars more durable than manual ones?

Automatic cars deteriorate faster and are much less durable than manual cars of the same model.

Does automatic use more fuel?

In fact, automatic cars can be more fuel-efficient than manual cars, especially if they have a sophisticated auto transmission system with features like stop-start technology and adaptive cruise control.

Does an automatic car give less mileage?

Fuel consumption in cars with automatic transmissions is higher than in cars with manual transmissions. An automatic gearbox demands more energy to shift because it uses a torque converter that employs a fluid to transfer power from the engine to the gearbox.

Which car, automatic or manual, is cheaper to maintain?

Compared to manual transmissions, those that are automatic are slightly more complex. Many parts make up their structure, which may take mechanics a while to diagnose, accumulating more cost to a driver in the long run.

Are manual cars faster than automatic ones?

Manuals are fast, but automatics have evolved to a similar speed level, and not only AMTs and CVTs but also Automatic transmissions are now faster than manuals.

Are automatic cars good for hills?

Automatic cars do not have any issues with hills and inclines, and almost all of the new automatic cars that have come to the market are complemented by a hill-hold control feature.

Is manual more reliable than automatic?

Manuals are generally better as no intricate components can become a problem.

Is it costly to have car insurance for automatic cars?

The insurance cost of a car differs depending on its price and other factors. Automatic cars are more expensive to produce than manual ones, so the insurance cost is higher for automatic cars. However, cars with an AMT gearbox are fairly priced, and the insurance premium is also reasonable.

What should never be done in an automatic car?

Some of the essential things you should never do in an automatic car are:

It is important not to switch to neutral while descending a hill.
Never employ the reverse gear while the car is moving forward.
Avoid abusing the new vehicle by accelerating hard on the throttle, which may damage the gearbox and engine components.
Never shift the gear to neutral in a signal, as it does not conserve fuel or alter the car's nature.

How effective is an automatic car on roads like those in India, and should one consider buying one in India?

Definitely, and mainly if you are a resident of turbulent large cities with dynamic but slow-moving traffic, where you may have to stop and go several times. In addition to traffic, road conditions may force one to shift gears and use the clutch pedal several times, making the journey challenging and strenuous. Automatic cars are more convenient and are highly beneficial, especially in one of the most populous countries in the world, India. However, some drivers may prefer manual cars since they can control them completely.